CW: Harry Potter, JK Rowling, Transphobia, Shitty Allies.
So this past weekend it was announced that there was going to be a second official Harry Pottery knitting pattern book. Which I have no interest in as I have broken up with Harry Potter. (Trans live and feeling > fictional wizards and my nostalgia) But the kicker is that this author 1) had a post recently about Pride and supporting the Trans community and 2) it was announced in June, ya know, Pride month.
Current discussions are over
- The contracts: How tightly is the author stuck in one? Most contracts you can break, though they often result in a financial cost. Which leads the whole idea that if you are only an ally until it costs you something ($ or otherwise) then are you really an ally?
- The Designers involved: questions about if they truly support the Trans community or are they willing to give them up to make money
- The Yarn dyers involved: There is at least one dyer that has said that she gave yarn to the author because they have worked on past projects, without paying attention to the project that it would be going to
I am solidly of the notion that JK is a TERF, is not getting any more of my money. I will not be buying anything more either licensed products or products inspired by/ name after anything from HP/Wizarding World. I recently referred this change in attitude as my break up with HP.
I am disappointed that the author of this book 1) put it out at all, 2) is posting super excited posts about it, 3) is not even considering donating a portion of the sales to an Tran- led organization as a way to make sure she is not profiting from something that hurts a community she claims to care about.
I am going to review the designers that contributed designs to this book and will probably take them off my list of designers to support.
As for the yarn dyers? This is the sticky one for me. Those like the one that admitted they didn't review what the topic was and made an apology, she does do a lot of donations to organizations and was the first one involved to speak out about it. I will have to see what the others say.
Honestly I am finding it far easier to stick with a few yarn dyers and designers that I know have actions that support their works.